
Been reading people's posts on Smallville and Buffy, spoiler-whore that I am. And it occurs to me the problems with some shows.
Basically, there's some shows you sit there and go 'oooo', and happily lie back and bask. Sometimes bad or lazy, but these moments are few and far between. Or don't last that long. They take notice of their characters, keep 'em consistent or at least go with their arcs. Sometimes there's a bad part of a season, but overall you're happy.
Examples : Buffy, Angel, Farscape, Drop the Dead Donkey, Robin of Sherwood.
Then there's the kind of show which - well, you like the characters but they're continually being treated bad by the writers. You spend more of it wincing, complaining and desperately hoping for a ray of light than you do basking. And even part of the basking you're wincing at the dumb bits.
Example : Smallville.
This is my problem with Smallville. It has great bits, and I love the Clark/Lex, and Chloe, and Lionel, and Jonathan, and Martha... but christ, I hate the way the writers run roughshod over everyone to play with Lana and let her whine about her pain and issues. Who's not important to the storyline in any way whatsoever. She adds nothing to Clark's development like Lex does and we've been shown Chloe will. I spend half the show wanting to throw things at the screen. Christ, Casualty treats its characters better. The average Eastenders or Corrie ep does. Which makes me wonder why I'm suffering through this. The writers appear to have no concept of the fact that Clark would've been got by the police, fingerprints, evidence of destruction, you name it. At least on Buffy they made the point of everyone being used to the weirdness, putting blinkers on on *purpose*, and police cover-up. Smallville it's just plain lazy. And each week the irritation builds as I wait fo rthose precious moments or infrequent good eps.